IS FASHION LOSING ITS IDENTITY?
On commercial pressure, creative freedom and an industry increasingly concerned with being seen rather than having something to say.
Let’s address the elephant in the room. Is fashion losing its identity?
Fashion has always been about expression. An opportunity to communicate something without necessarily having to say anything. It has been a reflection of identity, culture, individuality and, at its best, a space for people to challenge what already exists.
But lately, something feels different.
Look around and it’s becoming increasingly difficult to distinguish one thing from another. The same silhouettes, the same aesthetics, the same references and the same ideas circulating between brands, designers and social media.
Something gains attention, and almost immediately, variations of it begin appearing everywhere.
It raises a question: are we witnessing a lack of originality in fashion, or has the industry become so concerned with commercial success that it is gradually losing sight of what made it interesting in the first place?
THE DOMINO EFFECT OF COMMERCIAL FASHION
I think fashion has become far too commercially driven.
And this isn’t something exclusive to the established luxury houses. It’s something that has filtered through the entire industry, from the biggest names in fashion to the smallest independent brands.
There is an increasing emphasis on producing what sells, rather than creating what challenges, excites or pushes things forward.
Of course, fashion is an industry. Brands need to make money, businesses need to survive and commercial success will always play a part in the creative process. But when commercial considerations begin to dictate almost every creative decision, something inevitably gets lost.
What makes this particularly interesting is the domino effect it creates.
When the biggest fashion houses begin prioritising commercially safe collections, it sets a certain expectation for the rest of the industry. Smaller brands observe what is working at the top and naturally begin to follow similar directions.
Before long, everyone is referencing the same things, producing similar products and attempting to capture the same audience.
Copy and paste. Copy and paste.
And somewhere in that process, the people taking genuine creative risks become increasingly difficult to accommodate.
Their work might be unfamiliar. It might challenge what people are accustomed to seeing. It might not immediately translate into something commercially desirable.
So it gets overlooked.
Not necessarily because the work lacks merit, but because it doesn’t fit within what the industry, or its audience, has become accustomed to recognising.
Perhaps this is where the identity crisis begins. When originality becomes harder to sell, and familiarity becomes easier to market, the industry inevitably starts moving towards the familiar.
WHEN DID EVERYTHING BECOME ABOUT BEING SEEN?
Social media has undoubtedly changed the creative industry.
It has opened doors that previously didn’t exist. Independent designers can now reach international audiences, artists can showcase their work without institutional backing and emerging brands can build communities from the ground up.
That accessibility is valuable.
But I think the creative industry has become increasingly dependent on the online world, and in doing so, has lost some of its offline momentum.
Everything is now measured through visibility. Followers, engagement, impressions, views, growth and algorithms.
A brand can spend more time thinking about how something will perform online than the actual experience of creating it.
And I think that’s a problem.
Because online, you don’t necessarily get to experience the personality behind a brand. You see the campaign, the imagery, the product and the numbers. You see what is performing well and what everyone else seems to be paying attention to.
But popularity and independence are not the same thing.
Social media rewards attention. It rewards familiarity, consistency and whatever happens to capture the audience at a particular moment. But genuine creative independence doesn’t always fit neatly into those expectations.
Some of the most interesting work isn’t necessarily going to be the most popular. Some of the most talented designers aren’t going to have the biggest followings. And some of the most worthwhile creative experiences cannot be replicated through a screen.
There is something about discovering a brand in person, speaking to the person behind it, seeing the construction of a garment up close or coming across something you weren’t necessarily looking for.
That experience has a different value.
And perhaps the creative industry needs to rediscover more of it.
This is part of the reason we believe in creating physical spaces for discovery. Not everything should happen online. There should still be opportunities for people to meet, exchange ideas, experience creativity and discover things organically.
Because culture doesn’t just exist on a screen.
THE INDEPENDENT ADVANTAGE
I sometimes find independent designers more interesting than established fashion houses.
Not because independent fashion is automatically better, or because established houses have lost their ability to innovate, but because independent designers can operate with a different kind of freedom.
They aren’t necessarily carrying the same expectations, commercial obligations or institutional pressures.
They can experiment, make mistakes, change direction and explore ideas without having to satisfy an established audience or protect a legacy.
And there’s another element to this that I find particularly interesting.
Independent fashion often doesn’t have the budgets.
That might sound like a disadvantage, and financially, it obviously can be. But creatively, I think it can produce some of the most interesting results.
When you don’t have the resources to execute an idea in the conventional way, you have to think differently.
How can I achieve this with what I have? How can I make this work without the budget? How can I create something that communicates the same idea through a completely different approach?
Those limitations can force you to become more resourceful, more inventive and more experimental.
Sometimes, having everything available to you removes the need to think outside the box.
Of course, a lack of funding also creates real barriers. It shouldn’t be romanticised, and independent designers deserve the resources and opportunities to realise their ambitions.
But there is something valuable in the freedom that comes from having fewer expectations placed upon you.
Some of the most interesting creative decisions happen when there isn’t an obvious solution.
And perhaps that’s something the wider industry could learn from.
SO, WHERE DOES FASHION GO FROM HERE?
I don’t think fashion has run out of creativity.
There are still designers pushing boundaries, independent brands developing their own identities, artists challenging conventions and creatives producing work that feels genuinely different.
But I do think the environment in which creativity exists has changed.
There is more pressure to be visible, more pressure to be commercially successful and more pressure to remain relevant.
And when everyone is looking in the same direction, it becomes increasingly difficult to see what’s happening elsewhere.
Perhaps the answer isn’t another trend, another aesthetic or another attempt to predict what people will want next.
Perhaps it’s about giving creativity room to exist outside of those expectations.
More experimentation. More individuality. More physical spaces for discovery. More opportunities for independent voices to be seen and experienced on their own terms.
We don’t necessarily need everyone to agree on what is good, what is relevant or what fashion should look like.
In fact, that would probably defeat the point.
Fashion is at its most interesting when there is room for different perspectives, different approaches and ideas that don’t always make immediate sense.
Maybe the industry doesn’t need more people following the same direction.
Maybe it needs more people willing to go somewhere else.